Welcome to Pizzalley's Pizzeria on historic St. George St.

Following the aroma of simmering herbs and spices
while meandering down historic St. George street,
you will soon find yourself greeted by one of our
charismatic samplers tempting you to
a morsel of gourmet, brick oven pizza.

Upon entry, our fast service à la carte pizza bar
allows for easy flow past tantalizing dishes,
including fresh salads, hot garlic breadsticks,
and our acclaimed Tortellini Pasta Salad.

Try our signature Italian dressing and you just might
be leaving with a bottle of your own.

Our mouth watering sub sandwiches and our crispy,
yet juicy, chicken wings are both served with our
unforgettable crinkle cut french fries prepared fresh daily.

However, that is just the beginning of the cavalcade
of flavors to entice your senses.
The crispiness of our crust and the flavor of our sauce
over the years has given us the distinction of
Saint Augustine's number one pizzeria.

Whether it's ordering our 16 inch pies or simply
purchasing pizza by the slice, our list of quality
toppings can be mixed and matched
to your heart's content.

If creativity isn't your strong suit, exploring our
13 gourmet specialty pizzas always ends with a smile.

By the slice or by the whole pie,
we have meat, greek, and roasted veggie lovers,
that you will most definitely adore.

Or go all out with an explosion of toppings,
with our aptly named (and kinda famous) Garbage Can pie.

So bring the family and share a pie or
stumble in for a hot slice and a cold beer.

Just be prepared to taste a pizza like none other in
the comfort of our historical dining alley
or in our secluded and enchanting courtyard.

We're ready to put a smile on your face!